All comments containing advertising links and/or swear word will not be approved and will be deleted!
Back to top

Review: My experience with microstock, Alamy vs Shutterstock vs Istock vs Dreamstime vs Depositphotos vs Canstock vs Fotolia.

The first time I used a camera was back in 2002 and it was not even mine. My passion for photography grew when I was using my colleague's camera in 2005. I got my first camera in 2007 as a gift, a Nikon Coolpix S10 with that funny fancy swivel lens design. In 2012, I got my first DSLR and I though I was starting to take nice pictures. The idea of earning some money with something I like to do started to anchor in my mind.

I entered the world of stock photography in 2014 after a long thought (1.5 years) between Alamy and microstock sites. Back then, to my knowledge, Alamy pays decent amount of money while microstock gives you 30 to 50 cents per image. Come on, what the heck 30 cents! Of course, I was aware of those reviews about microstock sites saying that the number of downloads would outweigh the "good pay" at Alamy but I was not convinced. I decided to upload my images on Alamy. I was uploading and uploading and waiting and waiting for some sells but nothing happened. I uploaded about 200 pictures but did not sell any. You can view my Alamy portfolio here and have a laugh at it!

First alamy sell

This year, 2016, in January, I sold my first picture on Alamy. It was one of those photos that made people laugh and said come on, you are joking right? You will not upload that piece of ..., will you? Anyway, that first sale earned me $48 which is about 140 000 MGA (I am from Madagascar). It was still below the minimum payout threshold ($75) but anyway, that first sale woke me up after 2 years of silence. I started to upload pictures to Alamy again.

However, I also did some simple maths. I have been with Alamy for 2 years and I got $47, which is about 6 cents a day or 24 cents/photo if each picture was sold once. What the … 6 cents a day, 24 cents/photo! OK, I decided to upload photo to microstock sites as well! I know my portfolio is not a typical stock shot, the Alamy experience seems to tell soo, but I decided to give it a try anyway. I signed up to become a contributor at Shutterstock, Depositphotos, Istock, Dreamstime, Canstock and Fotolia and was accepted right away. I was quite surprised, but let say I uploaded my very best shots. So I started to upload photo at those 6 microstock sites as well.

My first Shutterstock sell

My first microstock sell was at Shutterstock. Then I sold a picture every 2nd day. On the other hand, despite the same amount of uploaded pictures, the other sites did not give me anything yet! I felt like … and start to think that my work must suck. Despite such disappointment, I kept uploading but my earning was not increasing at all. A month after I sold about 1 a day at Shutterstock while having a portfolio of 50 pictures. By the time, I sold one picture, respectively, at Dreamstime, Depositphotos and Istock. Canstock and Fotolia were still at big 0.

The situation pissed me off. With all the time I spent manipulating, uploading and keywording those photos I’ve got $7 (All microstock sites combined). I decided to withdraw all my photos at Canstock and Fotolia and cancelled my account. I was also trying to withdraw all my photo at Dreamstime but it did not allow me to delete all of them. So I still have some photos there. I also thought maybe it is not bad to have some photos hanging around there. I had a feeling that some people find my picture at Dreamstime, Depositphotos or Istock then went to buy them at Shutterstock because the files I sold at Shutterstock were the most viewed at the other stock sites. This is a pure speculation though. Anyway, I kept uploading photos at Shutterstock, my portfolio was around 200 photos when I got my first payment, 3 months after I joined in. It was not a big earning, just at the minimum payment threshold.

Back at Alamy, I sold my second picture in May. It was a big sale of $280 which should bring me $140 once minus the 50% commission. Before I continue, I want to clarify something about Alamy earning. Like any other stock agencies, they have a minimum payment threshold which is $75. What makes Alamy "special" is that they have what they call uncleared balanced and cleared balanced. Uncleared balanced is the money you may get "if ever" Alamy get payment from the "buyer". So basically they give away your picture for free with just promises from the so called buyer. Once Alamy receives real payment, not a "fake one", then the money will arrive safely, at last, in you cleared balance. For my first sale, it takes 45 days until it was cleared. To my surprise, my "big sale" was refunded in June then re-bought (probably by the same person) immediately at $300. Alamy sent me a congratulation email and suggested me to tweet about it but I did not. I will not be happy until that money lays safely in my paypal account! It has been 2 months now and still that "big sale" is laying safely in my uncleared balance. Some Alamy contributor made a joke at the Alamy forum that the $75 is an impossible to reach threshold as any so call "big sale" will be just refunded. Other contributors complained that their "big sales" keep being refunded and bought back … just google Alamy uncleared cleared balance refund" if you want to read more. I just hope it will arrive into my paypal account at some point. For now that $198 in the air is not better than $35 in my paypal account from Shutterstock!

So now, so far I have:

  • 300 pictures online at Shutterstock. I sell about 2 pictures a day.
  • 240 pictures at Depositphotos here which gave me $2.13 since I signed up in end April
  • 30 pictures at Dreamstime which gave me $0.70 so far
  • 96 pictures at Istock which gave me $4.6 so far
  • 391 pictures at Alamy which gave me $47 of cleared balance and $150 of uncleared balanced which may never clear out!

So was it worth it? Well, my stock experience is not that great I agree. However, as I mentioned in the beginning of this post, I do not have a typical microstock portfolio. In addition, people say that you need a fat portfolio of thousand of pictures to make significant earning out of it. In my case, I would sell about 7 pictures a day with 1000 pictures uploaded at Shutterstock and I think I do not have time for that yet! Uploading one file cost me 25 cents (internet bandwidth) and the keywording is just a pain. However, bad keywording will degrade your file’s performance. Even great photo will not sell if buyer does not find it. Remember, there are almost 100 million of photos at Shutterstock alone!

For me microstock is the place were you want to kill spare time (I would rather go out and enjoy my spare time instead). But anyway, the only way to find out if microstock is for you is to try it your self. My recommendation (feel free to ignore them completely, I am a failed microstocker after all) is to upload your file at Shutterstock. It is the site for beginner and if you do not sell anything there, very likely the other sites will not be better!

To try selling your file at Shutterstock, register here. It is free, and quick, nothing to lose, except your time ;-)
If you want to check the other microstock sites, you can register at Depositphotos here OR
Dreamstime here OR
Istock here OR
Alamy here.
People said as well that Fotolia is getting better and catching up. If you want to register at Fotolia then click here
There are also plenty of other stock sites out there!

Good luck and may the camera be with you!

Comments

Interesting article.

Interesting article.

I've been on Alamy for about 2 years and have 1,800 image portfolio and few downloads. I tend to only upload my premium images + editorials. Whereas SS get my non-premium stuff.

I'm putting together a book called "The Brutally Honest Guide to Microstock Photography", which I think you will find interesting.

Keep writing, you have nice articles.

Best regards,

Alex
www.arotenberg.photoshelter.com

I have been with Alamy about

I have been with Alamy about 12 years and have about 3000 images, mainly mediocre if I am honest. I have made about $6000 over this time with my biggest sale about $1000. I have not uploaded for a while now but still get about $200-300 per year. I am not a professional photographer. The best sales are very simple images. Not necessarily the ones you like best and would show to friends. As long as they are technically competent someone might want them. I once sold 2 photos of close up images of a woolly jumper showing the fibres and texture!

We my hubby and i are old

We my hubby and i are old school photographers. I am getting very discourged by all this. Which stock website would you say is the best place to sell your photos these day?

I just entered the arena of

I just entered the arena of microstock in December of 2016 after realizing I kinda enjoyed photography and probably should give it a go. Now, only 3 months later, after dealing with titles, descriptions, keywords, jaded reviewers, limited sales and shrinking exposure, I've come to the conclusion that the market is simply over saturated with pictures of every atom on the planet. I swear no matter what idea I come up with somehow someone somewhere has already taken a similar photo with a better camera and lens. And, potential buyers have to sift through the waves of clone pics in order to get one not so ordinary one. I have to say I do not enjoy doing anything for microstock and the payout for your time and effort is zilch! You might as well give your stuff away for free on Unsplash or Flickr. I think you have to be super awesome amazing deluxe top notch unique mixed with a little weirdness to make it nowadays. I began to remove photos from my portfolio and like you would like to enjoy my time rather than waste it cataloging images that will never sell.

Hi Shawn,

Hi Shawn,

Sorry to hear that you also had the same experience as I did.
However, things happened last month. I sold 4 movies I uploaded year ago. Now I'm wondering, maybe the movie business is not that saturated yet? But again, I just sold 5 movies so far. So is it worth it, I will let you reader to decide.

That's great! I wish you luck

That's great! I wish you luck with that venture. Right now, I'm in that evaluating phase thinking about whether or not the time and effort is worth the money. I too had some 15, 30 and 60 second video video clips on dreamstime, but have since removed them after seeing the whole $2.60 I made from photo sales over a 3 month period. lol! In my mind though I can still picture (no pun intended) creating that one clip or photo which sells thousands of times or just once to someone who wanted exclusive rights. I think it can happen, truly. So, instead of walking around with the intention of creating microstock or videostock, I think I'm going to just try and enjoy myself and throw stuff online now and then if I have nothing else to do. Time is just too precious :-)

I can relate to what you are

I can relate to what you are saying. I was on several stock sites and started pulling my work. I still have about 50 pics on dreamstime , and in 3 year made about fifteen dollars. I wouldn't say that is great. I am still trying to find a place to sell my photos. Seems like no one thinks decent photos are worth anything. I enjoy taking photos but would like to find some place which you can actually sell them for a decent price.

I'm back! It's been over 3

I'm back! It's been over 3 months since my last comment regarding this subject and I figured that I would report back how my experience is going so far. Since March I have been able to get media online at Shutterstock, Pond5 and Videoblocks. I'm still slowly removing my portfolio from dreamstime, as that agency seems to be overwhelmed with a huge amount of images flowing in per day. As a result I believe, for me anyway, their platform is simply a not going to provide decent exposure with buyer searches. When I joined dreamstime was touting a repository of approximately 52 million images and now they are up to 61.77 million as of today. Over 600,000 new pictures added this week. That is insane when I think about a buyer browsing or searching through that vast inventory. Unfortunately they only let you disable a small percentage of your portfolio and the rest must remain online for 6 months before you can finally remove them.

Shutterstock has been a slow and steady drip of 25 cent subscription sales plus 3 non subscription sales since March 4th 2017, for a grand total of 44 license purchases from my portfolio of 167 images, equaling a whopping $16.09

To give a little perspective, I have roughly $3,000 tied up in all my camera gear (strobes, lenses, batteries, tripods, etc.) This simply re affirms that doing microstock in photography may not be for me.
Pond5 has been interesting to upload to as nothing gets rejected for any reason. I know I vet my own images pretty well, but they seem to not care at all about what I’m uploading. I have an image portfolio of 218 on their site plus a video portfolio of 50 clips. No licenses for pictures have sold but I did finally sell one license today for a 19 second video clip which sold for $99.00 and my percentage was $49.50
Now, that one video sale has surpassed the total revenue made from all my picture sales combined. (dreamstime 12 sales $33.09 + shutterstock 44 sales $16.09 = $49.13) Doesn’t it seemed crazy to keep doing stock photos?

Videoblocks has all my videos, about 50 so far, but no sales whatsoever. Still early though. My guess is we have a small window of opportunity to take advantage of video licensing before that too becomes saturated with the ever growing drone footage and cell phone 4k clips. Gotta ride and jump off the train just before it crashes :-/

Yes, it's extremely

Yes, it's extremely frustrating but you can only really tell whether you're going in the right direction after about 1,000 images in 3+ quality agencies after one year. Anything less its just statistical noise. As for knowing what sells and what doesn't, just watch the first 20 minutes of a major 10 o'clock news bulletin...what are the major news? Then shoot around those (especially editorials).

I've recently started shooting footage as it's less competitive than photography, but i still have a long ways to go to improve technically.

I write a lot about how to make money at stock photography in my blog and have published a guide on the matter. Check it out at brutallyhonestmicrostock(dot)com

Good luck

Alex

Alex please stop visiting all

Alex please stop visiting all of these comments section trying to promote your book. From your other topics it is clear that you are not selling much of anything on microstock and that much of your work is straight out of the camera.

I am 1 year into stock, I

I am 1 year into stock, I made 1k in the first year, I am selling 8 photos a day now, looks like I will make more then 2k this year, I have like 20k invested on camera equipment, stock is 99% planing 1% talent, if you want to live from this you have to think this way, if something exists some one wants a photo of it, the more subjects you cover the more potential buyers..... I don’t do this for a living, I just love it, that’s why I have so much invested in it, and I normally resale my lenses for little or no loss.. my point is, if you are doing this for fun don’t let it become a job and take your joy away from it... some of.the mistakes I made were, I uploaded too many similars, I over keyworded, don’t listen to those that say to put as many keywords as posible, keep it close to the minimal possible, I do the 10 most important keywords for photo, I also didn’t diversify when I was shooting , I when to diferent cities and I didn’t take cityscapes for example, but my worst mistake was to upload photos that I didn’t consider my best.... when a buyer looks for a picture and one of yours shows in the search, you can’t control what of you photos will be on top, so likely the one ugly photo you uploaded is the one the buyer will see and he won’t click on your portfolio

Thanks for passing by. 1K in

Thanks for passing by. 1K in a year is impressive, Congratulation!!! I have been with Shutterstock for 3 years and still at 1.6K!
Anyway, as you said it cannot replace your job but instead of having the photo staying in the computer why not sell them. By the way do you also upload video? I tried but did not get much success so far :-(

I am a newer one on

I am a newer one on microstock. I had sold 4 photos on Shutterstock in June 2019. However, I had no any sell on depositphotos, Getty images and 123RF. Now, I am in delusions whether I should open an account on Alamy and Dreamstime or Not?

My recommendation is to keep

My recommendation is to keep uploading at Shutterstock. Try uploading some video as well, some people claim to get 1K a month from video :-o
I just reached my very first minimum payout from Depositphotos. That's 3 years for 50$. I asked for payout and as soon as I receive my money, I will cancel my account there. Not worth it in my opinion.
Getty used to be the Shutterstock competitor in my microstock earning but not now any longer. Since istock merged with Getty they changed the licensing system. Now some of my image get 0.001 Cent per download, not a mistake really 0.001 Cent!!! I was disappointed and decided to not upload there anymore. Did not delete my portfolio but not worth spending time uploading!
Alamy is very very slow, however, some sale may make you dance! I sell about 2 photos a year at Alamy. The thing about alamy is that they are pretty good if you are from the UK and shoot newsworthy photos (at least that's what people said)
Dreamstime: I gave up long long time ago
123RF: well I tried it as well, I have about 500 photos there and so far (about 2 year) and only got 34$

Thank you so much.

Thank you so much.
I am uploading photos slowly on Shutterstock as well as Getty. In 4 months, I sold 1 in Getty and 32 in Shutterstock. But, the acceptance ratio in Shutterstock is too low. Sometimes, they accept all. Sometimes, none even all photos are capture on the same scene except timing. However, acceptance in Getty is pretty good. Could you suggest any idea for higher acceptance in Shutterstock?

You are welcome.

You are welcome.
My suggestion is to upload only a few photos at a time. Also, wait for the submission review before submitting the next batch. The thing with microstock is, the more often you have gotten an accepted batch, the smoother the review!
Do you also upload videos or just photos? The video sale is rare but when it happen it is worth it. Last month I sold one video for 180$ at Shutterstock!! That is the equivalent of the earning of 540 photos.
I stopped uploading at Getty, too few sales and two low rates (sometimes 0.001 cent per photo or even a minus balance as the client was refunded).
Good luck and keep shooting!

Hello everyone.

Hello everyone.
This might be a little to late for the topic, but here goes my insight...

I studied Professional Photography in Washington DC back in 2000. I was off and on doing photos around the US until a friend told me in 2009 that I should start selling my photos on stock. I had no clue what or how to do any of that! I started my research and gathered my best 10 photos and submitted to Shutterstock. I started with them after investigating which were the best microstock companies in the market at the time and Shutterstock seemed decent.
My first submission was rejected, even though I studied their requirements very carefully. I studied again, resubmitted and was rejected again! I Decided to give it one last try, choosing more specific photos and according to what they wanted. I finally got accepted.
As you guys also mention, it took a long time to sell a single photo, but after many months of uploading and waiting I finally made a sale.
Time has passed, and now I've sold my photos 4,474 times, making over $2.500 usd.
After a year or so I decided to start submitting to more companies. I had the time and patience, which is extremely important for all this, so I said "why not?'
Now, I'm submitting, besides Shutterstock, to Fotolia (now Adobe Stock), iStockphoto (from Getty), Dreamstime, Depositphotos, 123RF, Canstock, Yaymicro, BIGstock (from Shutterstock), and starting today Alamy. With the rest of microstock companies combined (without counting Shutterstock) I've made only around $1000 in almost 7 years, give or take. So, not so good.
Companies that I absolutely DO NOT recommend of these mentioned are Yaymicro and Canstock. On Yaymicro I have around 750 images, in around 5 years of submitting, and I have sold $0.00! Not a single image. So, don't bother. I'm no photography genius but I'm not bad either. So, as of today, I will no longer bother with Yaymicro. With Canstock on the other hand I've made only $55 in around 7 years, and they are really problematic with the keywords, meaning, you set appropriate keywords and they refuse the photo due to that they think the keywords are incorrect and you have to edit and resend - very time consuming - and besides, you cannot send photos as editorial, so many of your shots will be rejected, unless you have model or property releases, which in most cases are impossible to get. I dislike them a lot.
Adobe stock has made improvements since it changed from Fotolia. Haven't made much with them but the site is very user friendly, and Adobe is a well established and reliable company.
BIGstock and 123RF are a hassle when it comes to uploading and I've made very little with them.

I wanted to ask you appreciated colleagues :) if Alamy is worth the time, and find out why is it that they pay more than the rest? If I submitted my successful Shutterstock photos to Alamy, could I make some decent $$?
Just in case you want to check out my Shutterstock, this is my link: https://www.shutterstock.com/g/alanbrito
And my Photo website: www.alanfalcony.com
Thank you all, and best regards!

Hello everyone.

Hello everyone.
This might be a little to late for the topic, but here goes my insight...

I studied Professional Photography in Washington DC back in 2000. I was off and on doing photos around the US until a friend told me in 2009 that I should start selling my photos on stock. I had no clue what or how to do any of that! I started my research and gathered my best 10 photos and submitted to Shutterstock. I started with them after investigating which were the best microstock companies in the market at the time and Shutterstock seemed decent.
My first submission was rejected, even though I studied their requirements very carefully. I studied again, resubmitted and was rejected again! I Decided to give it one last try, choosing more specific photos and according to what they wanted. I finally got accepted.
As you guys also mention, it took a long time to sell a single photo, but after many months of uploading and waiting I finally made a sale.
Time has passed, and now I've sold my photos 4,474 times, making over $2.500 usd.
After a year or so I decided to start submitting to more companies. I had the time and patience, which is extremely important for all this, so I said "why not?'
Now, I'm submitting, besides Shutterstock, to Fotolia (now Adobe Stock), iStockphoto (from Getty), Dreamstime, Depositphotos, 123RF, Canstock, Yaymicro, BIGstock (from Shutterstock), and starting today Alamy. With the rest of microstock companies combined (without counting Shutterstock) I've made only around $1000 in almost 7 years, give or take. So, not so good.
Companies that I absolutely DO NOT recommend of these mentioned are Yaymicro and Canstock. On Yaymicro I have around 750 images, in around 5 years of submitting, and I have sold $0.00! Not a single image. So, don't bother. I'm no photography genius but I'm not bad either. So, as of today, I will no longer bother with Yaymicro. With Canstock on the other hand I've made only $55 in around 7 years, and they are really problematic with the keywords, meaning, you set appropriate keywords and they refuse the photo due to that they think the keywords are incorrect and you have to edit and resend - very time consuming - and besides, you cannot send photos as editorial, so many of your shots will be rejected, unless you have model or property releases, which in most cases are impossible to get. I dislike them a lot.
Adobe stock has made improvements since it changed from Fotolia. Haven't made much with them but the site is very user friendly, and Adobe is a well established and reliable company.
BIGstock and 123RF are a hassle when it comes to uploading and I've made very little with them.

I wanted to ask you appreciated colleagues :) if Alamy is worth the time, and find out why is it that they pay more than the rest? If I submitted my successful Shutterstock photos to Alamy, could I make some decent $$?

Thank you all, and best regards!

It is a bit late but my

It is a bit late but my thought about Alamy and all the other stock photo agency is that the industry is going down. While I made a luck $400 i 2016 (3 downloads), 2017 went down to $190 (3 downloads), 2018 down to $50 (x downloads), went up a bit to $100 in 2019 and this year 0 download so far!
Shutterstock just changed its royalty rate and it is now worse than iStock/Getty. For more details read my recent post on this Shutterstock new earning structure.

I was astonished to see today

I was astonished to see today that Shutterstock sold my two videos at 58$ and I got a comission of 0,58$!!! They became a real scam!

Add new comment

All comments containing advertising links and/or swear word will not be approved and will be deleted!